Submission Guidelines for 13th Annual MSSNY Resident/Fellow and Medical Student Poster Symposium
March 23, 2018, 2:00 pm – 4:30 pm
MSSNY House of Delegates Meeting*
Adam's Mark Hotel
Buffalo, New York
1. Submission Rules
a) MSSNY medical student and resident/fellow members are invited to submit abstracts to be considered for poster presentation. (Please note that medical student membership requires enrollment in a LCME or COCA accredited school. However, non-LCME/COCA students doing rotations in New York hospitals may participate without membership.)
b) A $50 non-refundable symposium entry fee will be charged upon abstract submission. Many of our participants receive reimbursement from their programs, so check with yours.
c) Deadline for abstract submission is 4:00 pm on Friday, January 5, 2018.
d) We can only guarantee scoring of the first 100 resident/fellow abstracts and the first 40 student abstracts received. If we have enough abstract scorers, we will score more. Abstracts must be scored to be considered for poster presentation. We will refund any fees paid for abstracts over the 100/40 that are not able to be scored.
e) The top 50 resident/fellow and top 20 medical student scores will be invited to present posters in March.
f) Each applicant may submit only one abstract.
g) Those submitting abstracts for consideration must be first authors of the research.
h) You must be a MSSNY member to participate (see student exception in a) above). All dues must be up to date. Co-authors are not required to be MSSNY members.
i) Non-member first authors must apply for MSSNY membership. First time resident/fellow membership is free. If you are a former MSSNY resident member, you will have to rejoin and pay current dues. Residents and students can join online at www.mssny.org.
j) All submissions must be original works of individuals actively engaged in residency or fellowship training, or enrolled in medical school.
k) Posters previously entered in a MSSNY symposium cannot be resubmitted.
l) Entries may have been published in abstract form elsewhere, but may not be taken from previously published papers. (Authors should also be aware that acceptance at this meeting may preclude an abstract’s candidacy for submission elsewhere.)
m) Authors of entries accepted for the symposium must be able to attend the meeting and be present to discuss their submissions.
n) All submitters will be notified via e-mail regarding acceptance or rejection of their abstracts as soon as all abstracts have been scored. MAKE SURE TO PROVIDE AN EMAIL ADDRESS THAT YOU LOOK AT! We will use only one email address per participant.
o) Questions? Email email@example.com or call 516-488-6100 x 383.
2. Abstract Categories
a) Resident/Fellows may submit entries in one of two categories:
1. Clinical Medicine includes basic science, quality improvement, health policy, clinical research and medical education.
2. Clinical Vignettes involve the presentation of one or more patient encounters that illuminate unique observations of a known disease or describe a novel disease process; use of a new procedure, treatment or medication; medical mysteries; patient, family and physician relationships; ethical issues. These are expected to include clinical patient information, such as history, physical exam, and clinical data, as well as an analysis of how such observations might contribute to existing medical or scientific knowledge.
b) Medical students may submit abstracts of their scientific research (biochemistry/cell biology, cancer biology, clinical outcomes and healthcare improvement, immunology/infectious disease/inflammation, neurobiology/neuroscience, public health and epidemiology, radiology/imaging, surgery/biomedical engineering); clinical vignettes; or projects based in the social sciences and humanities, including alternative methodologies.
3. Abstract Criteria - PLEASE FOLLOW THESE INSTRUCTIONS CAREFULLY
a) Submit abstracts as email attachments in MS WORD, 10 point Arial font, to firstname.lastname@example.org. Deadline is Friday, January 5, 2018 at 4:00 pm.
b) To pay the $50 non-refundable entry fee
1. Pay online click here
2. Call 516-488-6100 extension 383 with credit card information
c) The following information must appear at the top of the abstracts:
1. For Vignettes: the specialty under which it falls (e.g. Cardiology, Nephrology, Hematology, etc.)
3. Authors’ names
4. Institution affiliations
5. As appropriate, entrant's medical school and graduation year (medical students); or PG year and expected date of completion of training; specialty (residents/fellows); address and email
d) Once an abstract is submitted, it cannot be modified (i.e., an updated version will not be accepted later, even if before the submission deadline). Please thoroughly proofread your abstract before submitting it.
e) Maximum length for research abstract is 250 words. Maximum length for vignette abstract is 400 words. Title, authors and institution affiliations are not included in word count. Do not include captions from photos or graphs in abstract text.
f) The body of the abstract should include, if applicable, background, methods, results and conclusions. Clinical medicine submissions should include clinical relevance.
g) Define all abbreviations in your abstract that are exclusive to your institution and not commonly used (to the best of your judgment).
h) Graphs, figures and photos should not be included in the submitted abstract, but should be incorporated into the poster for presentation at the meeting.
i) Authors may submit only one entry to the 2018 symposium.
j) Resident/fellow abstracts are scored on five criteria, each worth 0 to 5 points, for a maximum score of 25 points. The five criteria are:
1. Importance: innovation, relevance, creativity, new or cutting-edge information, originality of approach/intervention, significance or interest to the audience.
2. Methodology: appropriateness of conceptual basis and design for the identified purpose of the study, appropriateness of data collection techniques, development stage (level of data collection completeness); OR lessons learned: appropriateness of conceptual basis and design for the activity, extent to which the lessons learned merit the conclusions.
3. Clarity: development and communication of ideas and findings.
4. Conclusion consistent with data and/or observations. Potential pitfalls
of methodology or interpretation addressed. Potential significance of
experiments placed in proper perspective.
5. Abstract is in required form and organized, well written, concise, and readable.
k) Student abstracts are scored on five criteria, each worth 0 to 5 points, for a maximum score of 25 points. The five criteria are:
1. Project demonstrates a novel approach and/or idea.
2. Identification of all significant variables and clarity of efforts to eliminate bias between control and experimental groups; OR lessons learned: appropriateness of conceptual basis and design for the activity, extent to which the lessons learned merit the conclusions.
3. Clarity: Clear organization of project and evidence of effective use of scientific method.
4. Conclusion consistent with data and/or observations. Potential pitfalls of methodology or interpretation addressed. Potential significance of experiments placed in proper perspective.
5. Abstract is in required form and organized, well written, concise, and readable.
l) MSSNY RFS members may review abstracts submitted by medical students. Reviewing student abstracts does not disqualify resident/fellows from submitting their own abstracts.
m) Authors will be contacted via e-mail regarding acceptance or denial as soon as the abstract committee has made its selections.
4. Poster Presentation
a) Poster display boards will be provided.
b) Posters must fit within a board display area that is 6 feet wide by just under 4 feet high.
c) Push pins will be provided.
d) Posters should include title, authors, institution affiliations, and a detailed description of methods and results. Graphs, tables and photos are welcome on posters.
e) Poster text should be in 16 point font or larger.
f) No word count is assigned to poster text, but please limit narrative.
g) Posters will be displayed on boards in a gallery area, where entrants must be present to discuss their submissions.
h) Judges will visit and examine each presentation between 2:00 pm and approximately 4:00 pm. Authors must be available for questions during this time.
i) Between approximately 4:00 and 4:30 pm, participants are invited to circulate and visit each other's posters.
j) All participation costs are the responsibility of the entrants. If you leave your poster behind, MSSNY cannot guarantee its return.
5. Judging and Awards
a) Bring an 8 ½” x 11” copy of your poster and hand it in at the registration table; this will be a great aid to the judges as they conduct their final deliberations. Write your last name in the upper right corner of this copy.
b) A panel of poster competition judges will be selected by MSSNY prior to the meeting.
1. Each judge will assess approximately eight to ten posters.
2. Each contestant will be visited by at least one, but probably two or more judges.
3. Judges will be wearing a ribbon on their nametag marked “JUDGE.”
4. Judges will be assigned posters as they arrive at the symposium. They do not all come at once, so the actual start time for each individual's judging will vary. We respectfully request your patience.
5. Final judging will be done after the symposium. We regret that due to the exigencies of the meeting of which the symposium is a part, we cannot guarantee final results until later in the day or evening. Final results will be emailed to all participants as soon as possible.
c) Authors must be available for questions during the judging and are encouraged to prepare a 2-4 minute oral overview of their posters for the judges as they walk around.
d) Posters will be judged within their category and will be given a final grade, as follows:
6 criteria, each worth up to 10 points. Highest score = 60
1. ORIGINALITY: How original is the concept presented in the poster? Or, how original is the new approach to an old problem?
2. SIGNIFICANCE: How significant are the poster’s conclusions in increasing understanding of a disease process; in improving the diagnosis or treatment of a disease state; in disease prevention or health promotion?
3. PRESENTATION: How logical are the ideas presented in the poster? How interesting is the manner of presentation?
4. METHODS: How suitable is the research design for the stated objectives, and how appropriate are any statistical techniques applied? For case vignettes: are sound scientific principles used in analysis/interpretation/discussion?
5. VISUAL IMPACT: How effective is the poster visually? How valuable is each figure and graph in furthering viewers’ understanding of the research subject?
6. INTERVIEW: How knowledgeable and conversant is the presenting author with the research presented in the poster?
e) Residents/Fellows: There will be up to three awards per each category: first place, second place and honorable mention. Vignettes may have a third place category.
Students: There will be up to three awards in the student category: first place, second place and honorable mention.
f) Winners will receive an award certificate. We hope to be able to give first and second prize winners a monetary award. All poster contestants will receive a certificate of participation.
* The House of Delegates is an annual meeting during which MSSNY officers, councilors, trustees and designated delegates from county medical societies and recognized specialty societies formulate MSSNY policy and elect officers. Accepted symposium participants who wish to are invited to attend all meeting activities. A Daily Guide will be posted on the MSSNY website www.mssny.org as the meeting approaches.
Copyright © 2006 Medical Society of the State of New York (MSSNY) Legal Notice Site Map Contact Us